Artisan Pizza Napoletana is our top pick for pizza in Anguilla

It may not be the most traditional Caribbean cuisine but Artisan Pizza Napoletana serves pizza that is as good as any pizza being served up in Chicago, New York or even Rome.

What is Neapolitan / Napoletana Pizza?

According to Wikipedia Neapolitan pizza (Italian: pizza napoletana) is made with tomatoes and mozzarella cheese. It must be made with San Marzano tomatoes, which grow on the volcanic plains to the south of Mount Vesuvius, and mozzarella Campana, the DOP (PDO in English) version can be made with buffalo mozzarella cheese, ‘Mozzarella di Bufala Campana’ made with the milk from water buffalo raised in the marshlands of Campania and Lazio in a semi-wild state (this mozzarella is protected with its own European protected designation of origin).[1]

The Location

Artisan Pizza Napoletana

Artisan Pizza Napoletana is in Island Harbor, Anguilla. Tucked away, this place is a hidden gem that has tourists and locals alike coming back for more and more of the great pizza and other tasty Italian treats.

The Brick Oven

Artisan Pizza Napoletana

What makes the Pizza so good is the fact that it is baked in an authentic brick oven. There is no doubt that authentic brick oven pizza is a notch above anything else. The brick oven is not only used for pizza and many travelers love other dishes like the authentic calzones that are also made in the brick oven.

Island Style Artisan Pizza Napoletana

Everything about Artisan Pizza Napoletana is fresh and sometimes quite island funky. Like the Artisan Lobster Pizza. A truly island Caribbean pie of pizza with grape tomatoes, mozzarella, black pepper, lobster, parmesan, pecorino and fresh arugula to finish. It is pizza’s like this one that make Artisan’s so much more than just a pizza shop.

The Ingredients

Artisan Pizza Napoletana

Handmade pasta daily!

Artisan Pizza Napoletana

To ensure authentic Italian taste, most ingredients are imported. There is such integrity to the quality of the ingredients and the products that if the shipment is late the store may be closed. Check before you go. You should check before anyways as bookings for Artisan’s fill up quickly.


You could always ask for the Nutella Calzone!!

Artisan Pizza Napoletana

No Italian restaurant can claim a name to fame without finishing it off with distinction. In Italian terms this means Gelato. Artisan Pizza Napoletana makes delicious Gelato ice-cream, the best way to cleanse the palate after great pizza.


The ambience is relaxed with a romantic theme taking effect at night. It can be casual or high-end and that is one of it’s beauties.

Artisan Pizza Napoletana

Artisans really is one of our favorite island hangouts. It goes without saying we LOVE food & pizza if one of our favorites. Please share this article with friends you feel need a vacation and Anguilla could be the perfect spot for them. Thanks for reading, please sign up to our newsletter for updates.

If you are looking to stay in Anguilla & you want to eat at Artisan Pizza Napoletana 2 nearby options could be CeBlue Villas & Beach Resort ( $$$$ ) or also Fountain Shoal Bay. ( $ ) Both of these properties are quite close & convenient.

If you loved this article you could also read Dining options at Ceblue or our Top 10 Reasons To Visit Anguilla.